Index: /doc/branches/1.1/tutorial/my-first-project.txt
===================================================================
--- /doc/branches/1.1/tutorial/my-first-project.txt (revision 8669)
+++ /doc/branches/1.1/tutorial/my-first-project.txt (revision 8927)
@@ -470,5 +470,13 @@
     public function handleErrorUpdate()
     {
-      $this->forward('comment', 'create');
+      // forward it to edit if the id exists
+      if (!$this->getRequestParameter('id'))
+      {
+        $this->forward('comment', 'create');
+      }
+      else
+      {
+        $this->forward('comment', 'edit');
+      }
     }
 
Index: /doc/branches/1.0/tutorial/my-first-project.txt
===================================================================
--- /doc/branches/1.0/tutorial/my-first-project.txt (revision 8669)
+++ /doc/branches/1.0/tutorial/my-first-project.txt (revision 8927)
@@ -405,5 +405,13 @@
     public function handleErrorUpdate()
     {
-      $this->forward('comment', 'create');
+      // forward it to edit if the id exists
+      if (!$this->getRequestParameter('id'))
+      {
+        $this->forward('comment', 'create');
+      }
+      else
+      {
+        $this->forward('comment', 'edit');
+      }
     }